Amara Cay Resort Islamorada

Name: Amara Cay Resort
Address: 80001 Overseas Highway
Price range: 2

Check Availability

Islamorada

Dec 16, 2025 - Dec 17, 2025

Find

Contact Information

✉️ reservations@islamoradaresortcollection.com

🔗 Website

13056440073

📍 80001 Overseas Highway

3+
images

Amara Cay Resort Review

The 4-star Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada provides guests with a welcoming and comfortable ambiance. The property features charming details such as rough-hewn wooden beams, faux skipping-stone flooring, bleached wood paneling, and an adorned wall in the lobby with antique ships' keys. This boutique resort offers intimate and personalized spaces for celebrations, while still providing access to the amenities and experiences of three sister resorts in the Islamorada Resort Collection. It is the perfect destination for those seeking a memorable experience in the Florida Keys.

At The Amara Cay Resort, guests can enjoy a vibrant and captivating sunset experience with the ever-changing colors of the horizon. The resort offers exciting activities like paddleboarding and snorkeling, allowing guests to make the most of their time in Islamorada. Dining options at the resort include ReelCatch, which serves a selection of grab-and-go breakfast bites, fresh seafood dishes, and hand-crafted island drinks. The Tiki Bar and Kokomo pool bar provide a breezy oasis for guests to enjoy classic American cuisine and tropical cocktails against the backdrop of blue skies and swaying palm trees.

The prime location of The Amara Cay Resort allows guests to explore nearby attractions such as art studios, churches, reefs, galleries, and historical museums. The resort is surrounded by local restaurants, shopping options, bars, and activities for guests to indulge in. Guests can easily access the resort from Miami, and transportation options and a shuttle service are available on the property for seamless travel experiences. The Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada, with its charming ambiance, array of amenities, and convenient location, offers guests a truly enjoyable and memorable stay in the Florida Keys.

The Amara Cay Resort boasts 110 elegant rooms, including Queen Suites, Standard King Rooms, and Standard Queen Rooms. Some rooms offer additional amenities such as a work desk, a sitting area, and a balcony with breathtaking sea views. The spacious Apt Villa rooms provide separate living areas, balconies, and climate control for added comfort. All rooms are equipped with conveniences like free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and coffee makers. The coastal chic ambiance, premium bedding, plush pillows, and upscale toiletries ensure a relaxing and enjoyable stay at the resort.

Families will find plenty of entertainment and activities to enjoy at The Amara Cay Resort. The resort offers a pool for families to take a dip in and various water sports and activities at the dock with wet slips. Two boat excursion partners provide opportunities for guests to explore the surrounding waters and have thrilling experiences. Additionally, families can enjoy the convenience of a complimentary shuttle, a fitness center, and a vibrant Tiki Bar.

Guests at The Amara Cay Resort can truly indulge in leisure amenities, including an outdoor heated swimming pool with a shallow end and a sun terrace with comfortable loungers and beach umbrellas. The resort also provides direct beach access, allowing guests to enjoy the stunning beachfront views. For those looking for relaxation indoors, a leisure/TV room is available in a cozy and tranquil environment.